[C-safe-secure-studygroup] chat notes from call

[Laurence Urhegyi]

Thanks Robert,

We discussed today:

Rule 10.4: unanimous consensus to include a subset of the rule for both 
profiles. See here:

https://gitlab.com/trustable/C_Safety_and_Security_Rules_Study_Group/wikis/misrarule10.4

Rule 10.8: no consensus. See here:

https://gitlab.com/trustable/C_Safety_and_Security_Rules_Study_Group/wikis/misrarule10.8

Actions
- Robert to post summary of discussion on Rule 10.8 and ask for feedback 
from others on the list who cannot attend the meetings.



On 04/10/17 18:31, Robert Seacord wrote:
> 
> these are the chat notes from the call.  they are mostly from Clive who 
> wasn't able to use his audio connection.  I tried to remove the private 
> messages, even though none of them were even vaguely incriminating.
> 
> from Clive Pygott to Everyone:
> Hi Everyone
> from Clive Pygott to Everyone:
> There was on Aaron and me!
> from Aaron Ballman to Everyone:
> 10.4, Clive
> from Clive Pygott to Everyone:
> I'm voting yes
> from Clive Pygott to Everyone:
> Wrap around for unsigned is allowed
> from Clive Pygott to Everyone:
> Overflow in signed isn't
> from Clive Pygott to Everyone:
> Corection - Wrap arounf in unsigned ints isn't allowed in literal 
> expressions
> from Clive Pygott to Everyone:
> 10.6 isn't primarily about portability - its developer expectation
> from Clive Pygott to Everyone:
> The concern is that  the developer may think  ui32 = ui16 + ui16   is 
> calculatated int the target type
> from Clive Pygott to Everyone:
> MISRA C++ - not MISRA C!
> from Clive Pygott to Everyone:
> I don't think we are well coordinated as you think
> from Clive Pygott to Everyone:
> I believe that's correct
> from Clive Pygott to Everyone:
> I think the answer is No
> from Clive Pygott to Everyone:
> If it existed and worked, I and Fulvio would be out of work
> from Aaron Ballman to Everyone:
> That would be Very Bad. I'll make sure we don't open source our product. ;-)
> from Clive Pygott to Everyone:
> Yes
> from Clive Pygott to Everyone:
> Bye  In a couple of weeks I should be able to talk!
> from Clive Pygott to Everyone:
> I'll be there
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> C-safe-secure-studygroup mailing list
> C-safe-secure-studygroup at lists.trustable.io
> https://lists.trustable.io/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/c-safe-secure-studygroup
>